Why do I look fatter with more muscle?

Author: Jane Boehm  |  Last update: Thursday, August 14, 2025

Muscle weighs more than body fat A pound of lean muscle mass and a pound of body fat tissue might weigh the same, but they take up different amounts of space. This means that muscle and fat may look the same on the scale, but they'll look different on your body.

Why do I look fatter when I gain muscle?

Yes, muscle weight gained will, in general, produce hypertrophy or larger muscle size resulting in you looking bigger. Hypertrophy is usually defined as enlargement of a tissue due to an increase in the size of its cells. Muscle is a tissue, and this enlargement is what will make you look bigger.

Why am I gaining fat with muscle?

The reason you are gaining fat and not muscle is because you are working out too much, not eating enough, or eating the wrong foods. Your body needs the correct balance of protein, fat, and carbohydrates in order to grow muscle. If you are eating too many carbs, you have too much sugar flooding your system.

Why do I look so much bigger with a pump?

A pump is just blood going to your muscles. This makes them appear bigger because they are more saturated. When you workout a lot and gain weight, you also grow and look better. So yes you could say eventually you could look similar. There is no timeline, however.

Can muscle make me overweight?

BMI is not a perfect measure of weight or obesity. It often identifies fit, muscular people as being overweight or obese. That's because muscle is more dense than fat, and so weighs more.

How To Know If You're Gaining Muscle or Fat (6 Signs)

Why do I look skinny but weigh a lot?

If you've recently started dipping your toe (or your triceps) into strength training, that could have something to do with the discrepancy between the scale and the mirror. While it's a myth that muscle weighs more than fat—after all, a pound is a pound—it is denser, which means it takes up less space in the body.

Why does my BMI say I'm obese but I don't look obese?

A few people have high BMIs but don't have much body fat. Their muscle tissue pushes up their weight. Kahan points to very muscular people, like football players or body builders. “Their BMI shows up pretty high, and yet their body fat is actually pretty low," Kahan says.

Is it normal to look fatter after working out?

There are several research-backed reasons why you might notice a slight weight gain after exercise. These include muscle gain, water retention, post-workout inflammation, supplement use, or even undigested food. In most cases, post-workout weight gain is temporary.

Does drinking more water give you a bigger pump?

#1) Hydration

Keeping yourself full of water will have a dramatic effect on the blood flow in your body. Your blood is full of oxygen and water is made up of oxygen- so in order for the muscle to be oxygen rich (i.e. the pump) it needs to be filled with the nutrients that water carries into the body...

Why do I look fatter some days?

There are a variety of reasons why you may appear overweight one day and lean the next. It's usually not because you've gained a lot of body fat all of a sudden. Some of the reasons like water retention, the size of your last meal, psychological factors etc.

Why have I gained 10 pounds since working out?

Muscle is denser (meaning a lot less fluffy) than fat, says Dr. Calabrese. Put another way, 10 pounds of muscle takes up a lot less space than 10 pounds of fat. So, as you start working out regularly and building strength, the new muscle you build may eventually weigh more than the fat you've burnt off.

How to tell if weight gain is from muscle or fat?

Since muscle is denser than fat, if you've gained weight but your clothes fit a little looser, that's a good sign you may have gained muscle.

Why am I gaining weight if I barely eat?

If you're asking yourself, “Why am I gaining weight when I barely eat,” several factors may be at play. Your body may be holding onto fat stores if your eating habits are inconsistent or restricted. Or, your weight gain may be the effect of a sedentary lifestyle, medical condition, or long-term stress.

Is it normal to gain fat when you gain muscle?

Be prepared to gain some fat as well. It isn't possible to increase muscle mass without also increasing body fat.

Why do I look fatter in pictures than in the mirror?

Cameras can alter subject size depending on a multitude of factors like lens, camera settings, angles and lighting conditions. Wider-angle lenses, thick lenses and lenses with a short focal length cause more distortions and make the subject look bigger, while direct and harsh light has a similar result.

How long does water weight last?

How Long Does Water Weight Last? The span can vary depending on the cause. Temporary water weight caused by high sodium intake or premenstrual syndrome can last a few days to a week. Permanent water weight caused by underlying health conditions may last longer and require medical treatment.

Do muscular people need more water?

If you are an athlete or work out every day, you will need more water than someone just trying to stay in shape. The more often you exercise, the more water you'll need to consume. Your body has naturally become used to workout conditions, so it's essential to keep up with the fluid intake or risk dehydration.

Why do models drink so much water?

Models and celebrities often advocate drinking lots of water to help maintain clear, smooth skin. Some social media influencers have promoted drinking a gallon of water daily for weight loss.

Why do I look bigger after a pump?

It's the accumulation of blood and fluid inside the muscle that's responsible for giving you that pumped sensation. When you finish the set, your biceps look and feel a little bigger because they are.

Can building muscle make you look fatter?

The simple answer: No. Many people (especially females) are afraid that if they lift weights, they will get bulky (gain a lot of muscle mass), which inevitably changes their physique into what they may view as undesirable. Weight training does one thing very reliably: it makes you stronger.

Why is my belly getting bigger with exercise?

You May Be Consuming Extra Calories

Engaging in regular exercise may increase your appetite—especially if your body is burning more calories than it's used to. However, this is not a hard and fast rule. A 2023 review in Appetite reveals that it can go either way.

Why is my body fat increasing with exercise?

Working out can cause short-term weight gain as your muscle mass increases. Post-workout inflammation may cause temporary weight fluctuations. Workout plateaus, supplement use, and dietary changes can also stall your weight-loss efforts. Try not to obsess over the number on the scale.

What BMI is chubby?

This is what might politely be called the chubby category, with body mass indexes (a measure of weight for height) of 25 to 30. A woman, for instance, who is 5 feet 4 inches tall and weighs between 146 and 175 pounds.

What is hidden obese?

Hidden Obese means that the body has a high percentage of fat and a low level of muscle mass. Even though you might look like average from the outside, your fat levels are too high. This could lead to obesity, which could lead to serious health problems.

Previous article
Can most people run 20 mph?
Next article
What happens if you let your hair grow out?