What is better, Mederma or vitamin E?

Author: Gage Metz  |  Last update: Monday, June 16, 2025

Mederma: Although it is often recommended by physicians, this scar gel, which contains an onion extract, has no solid scientific evidence to support its use. Vitamin E: Although it is commonly used in anti-scarring products, clinical studies are disappointing.

Does vitamin E reduce scars?

Vitamin E is the main lipid-soluble antioxidant in the skin. Several anecdotal reports have suggested that topical use of vitamin E cream can reduce scar formation. Current evidence from the literature, however, does not support that proposition. In fact, studies report some adverse effects with use of vitamin E.

Does Mederma really reduce scars?

Mederma scar cream contains onion extract, which has been found in animal studies to help improve scarring. However, more research is needed to confirm these benefits for humans.

Does Mederma Advanced Scar Gel have vitamin E?

Vitamins A, C and E and rosehip oil to help improve skin tone. Hyaluronic acid, tripeptides and onion extract to smooth skin and reduce the appearance of scars.

Is vitamin E better than Mederma?

Mederma has an average rating of 2.3 out of 10 from a total of 11 ratings on Drugs.com. 10% of reviewers reported a positive effect, while 80% reported a negative effect. Vitamin e has an average rating of 5.5 out of 10 from a total of 6 ratings on Drugs.com.

Talking my Skincare for Melasma and Darkspot with Eucerin and how long do I use

How long does it take Mederma to fade scars?

Visibily Reduce Appearance of Scar

For best results, start using Mederma® Advanced Scar Gel as soon as your wound has closed and continue using daily for at least 8 weeks on new scars and 3-6 months on existing scars. Make sure the scab has come off naturally.

What are the disadvantages of using Mederma?

Serious side effects of Mederma

Signs of an allergic reaction, like rash; hives; itching; red, swollen, blistered, or peeling skin with or without fever; wheezing; tightness in the chest or throat; trouble breathing, swallowing, or talking; unusual hoarseness; or swelling of the mouth, face, lips, tongue, or throat.

Can Mederma remove 10 year old scars?

Treating an old scar does not differ much from treating a new scar. The notable difference will be the duration of treatment. The recommended treatment period with any of the Mederma® scar treatment products can be up to 6 months, or 8 weeks for new scars.

Is Vaseline better than Mederma?

Brown has reviewed at least three controlled studies showing no proven benefit when Mederma is used for scar treatment. You would see more benefit from applying lotion or Vaseline to a scar – three times per day for 8 weeks – than you would following the same regimen with Mederma.

What scar cream do plastic surgeons use?

BioCorneum® Scar Gel is the first and only quick drying silicone gel scar cream with SPF30 sunscreen that is approved by the FDA. This scar cream is an important part of our post-surgery scar care regimen, and we recommend it for most patients who have surgery or injuries in exposed areas such as the face.

Does vaseline help scars go away?

Cocoa butter cream and Vaseline are most often used to help reduce the appearance of scars. Applying the ointment daily will help heal scars but will not make them invisible. Another tip for caring for your scars includes surgery. Surgery will not eliminate the scar but can change its shape or make it less noticeable.

What vitamin is good for scars?

Many lay people use vitamin E on a regular basis to improve the outcome of scars and several physicians recommend topical vitamin E after skin surgery or resurfacing.

What heals scars the fastest?

Use silicone products

Silicone products, such as silicone sheets and gels, can keep your scar moisturized and help it heal. You can use them under your makeup and clothing.

How long does vitamin E take to remove scars?

Does vitamin E diminish scars? While vitamin E may help moisturize the skin, research indicates that vitamin E oils and supplements have no notable effect on scars. Vitamin E has a wide range of benefits, including keeping the eyes healthy and strengthening the immune system.

Does vitamin E cream work?

The ingredient is beneficial to most skin types, and has also been shown to relieve eczema for some people. That said, it won't work for everyone. "Vitamin E is usually not advisable for super sensitive, very oily, or acne-prone skin," Dr. Shamban says.

Is it too late to use Mederma?

You can begin using Mederma® Advanced Gel as soon as your wound has closed or your stitches have been removed. Mederma is not intended for use on open wounds. If a scab formed, wait until the scab falls off. While there is still a scab or stitches present, keep the wound clean and covered.

Can a 20 year old scar be removed?

Treatments can reduce a scar's size or appearance, but the scar will never completely go away. Some treatments prevent a scar from forming as a wound heals. Scar treatments include: Dermabrasion: A common acne scar treatment, dermabrasion removes the top layer of skin by gently “sanding” the skin.

Does Mederma remove dark spots?

It works but it is slow. It effectively removed light acne scars and almost removed the dark ones after using the gel for one month (applied it 2 times a day). Good thing is it doesn't damage the skin. A lot of dark spots removing cream damage the skin texture but no this gel!

Do dermatologists recommend Mederma?

Mederma Stretch Marks Therapy, Hydrates to Help Prevent Stretch Marks, Clinically Shown to Produce Noticable Improvement in 4 Weeks, Dermatologist Recommended, Ivory, 5.29 Ounce. The video showcases the product in use.

What are ice pick scars?

Ice-pick scars are a common type of scarring that can occur as a result of the acne healing process. They appear as small, sharp indentations that are wider at the skin's surface and narrow into a point as they reach down into the skin.

Why do my scars turn black?

Scar discoloration is primarily caused by: Increased Melanin Production: In response to inflammation and injury, the skin produces more melanin, leading to hyperpigmentation (Nautiyal & Wairkar, 2021). Vascular Changes: Increased blood flow and vessel formation contribute to erythematous scars (Fitzpatrick, 1994).

Can vaseline remove scars?

Use Vaseline® Jelly for Scars

By sealing in moisture it also helps to reduce dryness of scarred skin, once your skin has healed. This may help to improve the appearance of scars, making the skin look smoother and softer, as well as help to reduce itchiness caused by dryness.

Can Mederma remove 20 year old scars?

More doctors and pharmacists recommended Mederma than any other brand for older and newer scars. It works for many types of scars, including acne scars, surgery scars, and scars from burns, cuts, and other injuries. And since you only have to apply Mederma.

How can I speed up scar fading?

Treatment for scars
  1. silicone dressings or gels.
  2. steroid injections or cream.
  3. cryotherapy (a treatment to freeze the scar)
  4. laser therapy.
  5. skin camouflage (creams and powders you use to cover your scar)

Previous article
Do I shampoo after hair dye?
Next article
Is Dove a clarifying shampoo?