What is better for sore muscles, Tylenol or Ibuprofen?

Author: Caden Luettgen  |  Last update: Monday, September 29, 2025

So, which one should you use? Haley Morrissey, a clinical pharmacist for OSF HealthCare, has a general rule of thumb. “If you have muscle or skeletal pain or inflammation, go with ibuprofen,” Haley said. “If it's just a regular headache, acetaminophen is good.”

What painkiller is best for sore muscles?

Ibuprofen (trade names are Advil, Motrin, Midol) "targets inflammation, so it is particularly helpful for muscle pain, joint pain and sports injuries. For the winter, ibuprofen really comes in handy for sore throats.”

Which is better for muscle pain, ibuprofen or Tylenol?

Some feel acetaminophen works better for them, whereas others find ibuprofen better relieves a headache. Muscle ache or pulled/strained muscle. Ibuprofen typically works better for this kind of pain relief, due to the anti-inflammatory effects.

Why do doctors prefer Tylenol over ibuprofen?

If you're confused which to use, experts generally advise you to choose ibuprofen for inflammation and acetaminophen for just pain. If you aren't allergic and don't have liver problems, acetaminophen may be better for a simple headache than ibuprofen.

Does Tylenol reduce muscle inflammation?

What is acetaminophen? This OTC medicine is not an NSAID; it can ease mild-to-moderate pain and bring down a fever, and it tends to cause fewer stomach problems than other OTC pain relievers. But, unlike NSAIDs, it does not treat inflammation.

Where to Turn for Pain Relief or Inflammation (Aleve, Motrin, Advil, Tylenol) Dr. Mandell

How to soothe aching muscles?

Sore muscles after exercise
  1. apply ice packs.
  2. try massage.
  3. practice light stretching.
  4. take painkillers or anti-inflammatory medication if necessary.

What drink is good for muscle recovery?

Muscle Recovery Drinks
  • Beet Juice. Beets are amazingly healthy whether you cook or liquefy them, but juicing beets retains all of their nutritional value. ...
  • Tart Cherry Juice. ...
  • Golden Milk. ...
  • Green Tea. ...
  • Pomegranate Juice. ...
  • Watermelon Juice. ...
  • Bananas. ...
  • Berries.

Why do hospitals give Tylenol not Advil?

Hospitals tend to prefer acetaminophen (Tylenol) as a fever reducer and pain reliever because it has fewer side effects than ibuprofen (Advil).

What is the best tablet for muscle pain?

The best prescription muscle relaxants are baclofen, carisoprodol, methocarbamol, tizanidine, dantrolene, cyclobenzaprine, orphenadrine, chlorzoxazone, and metaxalone. Naproxen (Aleve) is one of the strongest OTC medications for muscle pain, cramps, and spasms.

When not to take ibuprofen?

Who may not be able to take ibuprofen
  • have ever had bleeding in your stomach or a hole (perforation) in your stomach caused by an NSAID.
  • have had a hole (perforation) in your stomach, bleeding in your stomach or a stomach ulcer more than once.
  • have a health problem that means you have an increased chance of bleeding.

What is the safest pain reliever for seniors?

Acetaminophen (Tylenol) is usually safer for older adults than other pain medicines. Topical pain medicines (also called topical analgesics) can also help. When common pain medicines don't work to manage pain, your healthcare provider may suggest other medicines, such as antidepressants or anticonvulsants.

Does ibuprofen help sore muscles?

The results of this study reveal that intake of ibuprofen can decrease muscle soreness induced after eccentric exercise but cannot assist in restoring muscle function.

Can you mix Tylenol and ibuprofen?

It's generally safe to take ibuprofen and Tylenol together because they work differently in the body and are cleared by different organs. You can also alternate between the two medications if your symptoms are spiking in-between doses of just one medication. Always follow the recommended dosing for both medications.

Should I take Tylenol or ibuprofen for muscle pain?

So, which one should you use? Haley Morrissey, a clinical pharmacist for OSF HealthCare, has a general rule of thumb. “If you have muscle or skeletal pain or inflammation, go with ibuprofen,” Haley said. “If it's just a regular headache, acetaminophen is good.”

What is the best home remedy for muscle pain?

Heat And Cold Packs

Alternating ice and heat therapy can be an effective way to ease muscle and joint pain. This method can help increase blood flow to muscles, loosen stiff joints and distract the brain from pain.

What pain pills are best for muscle pain?

Ibuprofen. Ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin) is an anti-inflammatory that can help treat pain, inflammation and fever. It may work better for certain symptoms or conditions. “I often recommend ibuprofen for menstrual cramps and sore muscles,” explains Dr. Miller.

What are the top 3 pain relievers?

The most common types of OTC pain medicines are acetaminophen, aspirin, and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs).

Why do doctors like Tylenol over ibuprofen?

Acetaminophen, on the other hand, is effective for general pain relief, such as headaches, toothaches, and general aches and pains. It also reduces fever and is less likely to cause stomach irritation, making it a better option for those with stomach issues.

Can I take 800 mg ibuprofen every 4 hours?

How often can I take it? In adults, the prescription dose of ibuprofen is 400 mg every 4 to 6 hours or 600 to 800 mg every 6 to 8 hours as needed, with a maximum dose of 3200 mg per day. The over-the-counter ibuprofen dose is 400 mg every 4 to 6 hours, with a maximum of 1200 mg per day.

Is Tylenol hard on your kidneys?

TYLENOL® does not impact the COX pathways that affect kidney function the way that NSAIDs can. In kidneys with some degree of dysfunction, NSAIDs' COX inhibition may4: Compromise renal function. Promote sodium and fluid retention.

Do bananas help muscle soreness?

Bananas, berries, spinach, and eggs are among the best foods for muscle recovery. Their nutrition profiles can help your muscles recover faster and even lessen next-day soreness. Stressing your muscles—regardless of your go-to exercise method—creates microscopic tears.

What is the best vitamin for sore muscles?

Supplementation with 1000 mg/d vitamin C for multiple weeks was shown to improve muscle force recovery and reduce post-exercise muscle soreness in untrained males following a 90 min intermittent run test [26].

How can I speed up muscle recovery?

While there's no silver bullet to avoiding muscle soreness, the following strategies may help during the recovery process:
  1. Eat right. ...
  2. Hydrate. ...
  3. Warm up. ...
  4. Cool down. ...
  5. Get a rubdown. ...
  6. Consider topical solutions. ...
  7. Roll it out. ...
  8. Keep moving.

Previous article
Can I still use green fake tan?
Next article
What to use instead of a self tan mitt?