Is box toner bad for your hair?

Author: Dr. Judy Feeney Jr.  |  Last update: Tuesday, September 16, 2025

Research shows that toner, when used correctly and as directed, usually does not damage hair. However, if left on the hair too long, used too frequently, or applied to already damaged hair, it can cause some damage.

Is store bought toner bad for your hair?

In short, toners are pretty safe to use on your hair without risking damage. While developer is used and that can rough up the cuticle (outer layer) a little, it will not damage the hair any more than it already may be.

Why do hairdressers say not to use box dye?

The level of chemicals in box dye is a much higher concentration than those used in salons due to the ``one size fits all'' nature of the mixture. This usually means that it's more drying and damaging in general for your hair.

Is toner better than box dye?

In summary, toners are best for color correction, subtle adjustments, short-term changes, maintaining highlights, and minimizing damage, while demi-permanent dyes are more suitable for longer-lasting color changes.

Is box dye actually bad for your hair?

Box dyes often contain strong chemicals that can over-processed hair, making it dry and brittle. These chemicals can react unpredictably with other hair treatments, causing damage.

Is Box Dye Bad For Your Hair?

What box dye is healthiest for your hair?

What Is the Best Natural Hair Dye?
  • Hally Color Cloud*
  • IROIRO Premium Natural Semi-Permanent Hair Color*
  • ARCTIC FOX's Vegan Semi-Permanent Dyes*
  • MANIC PANIC SuperNatural Hair Dyes*
  • Moroccanoil Color Depositing Mask*
  • Lime Crime Unicorn Semi-Permanent Hair*
  • Khadi Natural Hair Color*
  • Surya Brasil Henné Color*

What is the healthiest way to get box dye out of hair?

Vinegar rinse

Vinegar, especially apple cider vinegar, is a natural way to adjust hair's pH and fade color gently. It is often used as a natural alternative to clarifying shampoo. The acetic acid in vinegar helps to break down the dye, making it easier to wash out. To use, mix one part vinegar with two parts water.

Is toner more damaging than dye?

Is toner less damaging than hair dye? Yes, as studies show, toner is significantly safer for your hair than permanent dye. That is because it causes no structural harm to the hair fibre, but only coats the outsides of the strands.

Why do hairdressers use toner instead of dye?

Less hydrogen peroxide means that it's a healthier alternative to dye. For this reason, many stylists will opt for toner. Unfortunately this formulation also means that the results are semipermanent, rather than permanent. Every 3-4 weeks, hair toner will need to be refreshed to maintain the same shine and color.

Can toner cover grey hair?

Tresch also suggests using a gloss or toner like John Frieda Colour Refreshing Gloss or dpHUE Color Boosting GLOSS+ Deep Conditioning Treatment to easily camouflage sparse gray hairs.

What hair dye damages the most?

Comparing Permanent, Semi-Permanent, and Demi-Permanent Hair Dyes. Permanent hair color has the greatest potential for hair damage due to the chemistry involved and should be done most cautiously. Ammonia and hydrogen peroxide combine to open up the hair's cuticle to reach the internal structure and make a color change ...

What hair dye brands should I avoid?

Not Our Favorite Hair Dye / Hair Color Brands
  • Aveda (6 bad ingredients)
  • Calura (9 bad ingredients)
  • Clairol Nice'N Easy Color Crème (7 bad ingredients)
  • Clairol Nice & Easy Root Touch Up Semi-Permanent Colors AND Permanent Creme (7 bad ingredients)
  • Clairol Natural Instincts (6 bad ingredients)

How do you not damage your hair with box dye?

Deep conditioning improves the elasticity and strength of the hair by smoothing the shaft with intense moisture. "Follow your color application with a deep treatment mask," advises Ciceron., especially if you're using a home box dye.

What are the side effects of using toner on hair?

Your Hair is Dry and Brittle

The most common side effects of hair damage from toner are dry, brittle strands. If your hair feels dryer after using a toner, that's a sure sign the toner has impacted your hair health, and perhaps you should stop using it.

Is purple shampoo a toner?

Is purple shampoo a toner? Any product that dispenses pigment to adjust hair tone can be considered a toner, and that includes purple shampoo. Its pigments work to neutralize brass.

How often can you tone your hair without damaging it?

How Often Can You Tone Without Damaging Hair? Toning is great for achieving your client's dream shade or neutralizing any unwanted tones, but it's important to space out each appointment to keep the hair cuticles protected. Usually, we recommend waiting around four to eight weeks before repeating toning sessions.

What happens if you put toner on non dyed hair?

For those who don't have dyed hair, hair toner can still help diminish certain unwanted tones in your hair. For example, purple shampoo will reduce orange tones in blonde hair. It also acts as a top coat on your hair, so it provides a lot of shine and gloss.

What does toner do to brown hair?

Toning products work by depositing hair colour pigment onto each individual hair strand. Anyone can use hair toners regardless of whether your hair is dyed or not, but they're especially great at topping up faded colour, getting rid of those unwanted warm orange or brass tones, and adding intense shine.

Is toner just semi-permanent hair dye?

A Hair toner is a hair dye product that contains little or no ammonia and thus belongs to the group of demi-permanent or semi-permanent dyes.

Can toner mess your hair up?

Some toners contain harsh chemicals or high levels of ammonia or peroxide, which can strip the hair of its natural oils and cause damage if used incorrectly or excessively.

Is it unnecessary to use a toner?

Toners aren't a must-have part of a skin care routine because other products (serums, essences and moisturizers) can provide many of the same benefits. Toners are, however, a nice-to-have because they can take your routine to the next level.

Can hair toner cause hair loss?

No, toner itself can't damage hair, but if used too frequently or left on for too long, it can lead to scalp irritation and even cause hair to fall out. Hair toners contain chemicals and dyes that can eventually dry out and weaken the hair strands.

What box dye won't ruin my hair?

Garnier Olia Oil Powered Permanent Hair Color

A top performer in GH Beauty Lab testing, Garnier's permanent color is made with no ammonia and a high concentration of nourishing oil so it's gentle on hair that's damaged from treatments like keratin or thinning strands.

Does Dawn dish soap get box dye out of hair?

Dish Soap

Fortunately, if you go through the effort of using this drying soap on your dyed hair, it can help remove unwanted color. You'll need to do many washes to fade it out, but it is a step in the right direction if you want to remove a color.

How do I make my hair healthy after box dye?

How to take care of dyed hair
  1. Use The Right Shampoo. Avoid using harsh shampoos that will make your hair dull and damaged. ...
  2. Condition Well. Conditioning your hair regularly is an essential part of any hair regimen. ...
  3. Dry Naturally. Before styling, let your hair air dry as much as possible. ...
  4. Re-Color Often, But Not Too Often.

Previous article
Who is the most natural Kardashian?
Next article
How effective are vibrating massagers?